Angry scenes from outside a community meeting in Camden last night evoked frightening memories of the Cronulla Riots for many Muslim Australians.
Nearly 800 people turned up to the meeting called to protest plans for an Islamic school in the semi-rural town on Sydney’s outskirts. Police turned away around 100 people when the community hall where the meeting was staged became over-crowded.
Outside the Hall, young people draped in Australian flags, sported clothing and placards adorned with anti-Muslim slogans, chanted “Aussie, Aussie, Oi, Oi, Oi” and yelled racial abuse. One yobbo was caught on film threatening any Muslim who fronted with physical violence. This follows a recent hate crime at the site of the planned school involving the suspension of a pig's head between two stakes.
The school, which is proposed to accommodate 1200 students, would sit adjacent to an existing public school but it is being opposed on racial, religious and planning grounds by local residents. Over 2500 submissions have been made to the council with only 600 in support of the Islamic school proposal.
Inside the hall, NSW MLA, Rev. Fred Nile, was the keynote speaker at the meeting. He claimed Islamic schools were breeding grounds for terrorists. Fred Nile quoted from the Koran to justify his anti-Muslim stance. If he’d consulted his Bible and considered the example of Jesus who preached tolerance towards minorities he may have been able to represent a genuinely Christian perspective on the issue.
Nile’s Christian Democratic Party (CDP) campaigned against Muslim immigration at the Federal Election and is opposing both the Camden school proposal and one planned for Bass Hill. The Party’s number one NSW Senate candidate, Pastor Paul Green, ran on a platform of “No More Muslims, No More Mosques” and appeared in election propaganda wearing a tuxedo and bow tie. He preached disdain towards Muslims (bordering at times on hate-speech)on the campaign trail: “Every vote for the Christian Democratic Party is a vote for a ten year moratorium on Muslim immigration. And as a Senator I’ll be asking every Council in Australia to refuse all applications for new mosques until a Christian Church can legally be built in Saudi Arabia. Then Australian Muslims can have one mosque for every Christian Church built in Saudi Arabia." Neat argument – apply the standards of democracy practiced by Saudi Arabia. I thought Christianity had moved on from the principle of an “eye for an eye”?
Another NSW upper house MP, Liberal Charlie Lynn, also voiced his opposition to the proposal at the meeting – on planning grounds. This is the line which was also adopted by the Labor Party candidate for the seat with Kevin Rudd’s support during the election campaign.
Islamic groups - who were not invited to put their case to the meeting - said the tenor of the gathering and the political contributions were disappointing and irrational. The Quranic Society, which is behind the school proposal, told the ABC they just want to build a school for their children like a Catholic or Jewish school.
Tonight, members of the Community Relations Commission, the Police and the Camden Mayor have met in the town in an effort to ease community tension following the meeting.
This issue is a powder-keg. It highlights the racist undercurrent empowered by the dog-whistling of the Howard Government and the hate-speak of people like Pauline Hanson and the CDP. The result is a dangerous, racially driven mob mentality which has already crossed over into physical violence once at Cronulla.
History shows us powerful examples of the manifestation of racist mob violence fed by fear. In another time and place - Germany circa 1938 - Jewish people endured a night of horror called Kristallnacht (crystal night) which involved hordes of racists smashing thousands of Jewish shopkeepers’ windows and ransacking their homes. There are scary parallels between the rise of anti-Semitism in 1930’s Germany and the post-September 11th development of Islamophobia.
As I’ve argued before, Kevin Rudd must tackle Islamophobia head on and engage Australian Muslims in meaningful, cross-cultural bridge building exercises which he can drag the rest of Australia along with – kicking and screaming if need be. Failure to provide such national leadership will simply encourage racism to thrive and fuel the potential for hate-crimes and mob violence on the scale of Cronulla or worse.
20 December, 2007
Aussie, Aussie, Aussie! Shame, Shame, Shame!
Posted by
J-scribe
at
10:20 pm
Labels: camden muslim school islamophobia fred nile christian democratic party racism
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
6 comments:
I'd personally prefer it if all Catholic, Christian and Jewish schools were banned too.
When are agnostics/athiests going to stand up and say:
1) practice what you like but not at the expense of others.
2) all children should be given a secular education that is free of religious influence; except, perhaps, for a brief study of the world's major religions and their histories (without bias to one or another).
If we have to have religious schools, they should all be accepted (even "Jedi" schools) as long as they attest to not educate children in a way that assists them in forming views of a derogatory nature towards other religions or the non-religious. How would that be regulated? Who knows? But if it can't be regulated there shouldn't be ANY religious schools.
The Christian among you can cry all you want but no practice that encroaches on someone's human rights can be validated by popularity. Either the Muslim schools get built or you don't have yours. Don't forget - we are ALL Australians.
I have to say, I agree with the above comment.
I used to be an advocate of a publically multi-faith society but now I'm of the inclination that people ought to divorce church and belief from any sphere in which the young and impressionable are involved (which is most public institutions). I believe a child should only be given access to religious ideas after they've reached the age of reason, which is about ten or so.
Mind you, I'm a big nasty atheist these days, so I dislike all religion and tend to see it as an Inherently Corrupt Thing.
I'm a little more optimistic about faith and I do think religion is as valid as philosophy and politics in the life of a child.
And I support the rights of any religious community to establish a school as long as it complies with Australian law and education curricula. But I do believe such schools should be self-funding.
There is much of value to be found in religious faith - lessons about tolerance, love, justice for example. It's too easy and cliched to write off all religion as 'evil' and destructive.
I can see where you're coming from with your comments. I used to hold a non-confrontational, tolerant/accepting attitude to religion, dabbling my toes in it every now and again to keep my hand in the game, so to speak. My motives were my own, as are yours, but in my case I later discovered my assumed attitudes of fairness and tolerance were actually not that well thought out and were born more of a desire to appear PC and peaceful than any well-thought out response to the realities of the teachings of churches.
I am not saying that nobody should be allowed to believe, or to practice their belief. But I am saying that those rights should be tempered with respect to the young, the innocent and the vulnerable. Whilst I agree that there are many good principles that religions teach, there are just as many harmful, cruel and negligent practices and beliefs that remain unscrutinised because secularists do not want to appear intolerant. It is impossible to tease out the good from the bad in any religion because they are often inextricably intertwined and their exponents often tout the bad with as much fervour as the good and believe children are being done a wonderful favour under such influence.
Teaching a child how to make sound, ethical judgements based on the 'Golden Rule' is something that is accessible to all and does not require belief in supernatural powers or subscription to organisations laced with centuries of malignant dogma. To me, this is something much more desirable and a less volatile source of education for a child.
I offer you a challenge. Read "God is not Great: How Religion Poisons Everything" by Christopher Hitchens and see if it speaks to you at all - it is a robust and stimulating secular treatise. Despite the polemic of the title, it is a well researched and engaging read and anybody - believers, non-believers or distanced spectators - should be able to get something from it.
I'd go one further and say read: "The God Delusion" by Richard Dawkins (who tips his hat to Hitchens)...a more scientific approach perhaps, but rivetting.
I believe, unfortunately, that Dawkins is polemic to his detriment. No one will actually ever know if a higher power exists because:
1) any true power is completely beyond our comprehension
2) humans are incapable of understanding "truth", even under human contexts, interpretations and laws
What pisses me off (and I suspect it does my good buddy Veegs as well) is that athiests are now deciding they need to be arrogant and say they "know" God doesn't exist! Bullsh*t! No one knows (either way) and no one ever will.
That is why those of us who understand this, must argue against those who preach a dogma (as if they know the answers).
It is OK to say: "I believe ... because..." if and only if you also understand a range of other beliefs and have considered them. i.e. I don't mind if a child is given a range of arguements and then chooses one; so long as it is a conscious choice with knowledge of what else is out there.
I am going to write a book on this stuff one day...but for now I have to go the beach.
Ll out! x
I forgot to mention: I agree completely with The Vegan Apron on her (?) comments related to the actual dichotomies that exists in almost all religions. And I also agree that the part that is "good" (even divine?) in no way justifies the "bad".
I think faith (especially in other humans) is wonderful...and I am not anti-religion (if its followers understand their faith is personal and acknowledges a choice to worhsip without knowing; as opposed to knowing (first) and then worshipping as a consequence(usually in fear of not doing it)).
ps. Veegs...when I get back to Oz (between Sept & Chrissy) I propose you introduce this carnivore to the fineries of vegan cooking!
Post a Comment